The Confidence Trap: Why High Achievers Still Feel Like Impostors
- Kristi Baxter
- 3 days ago
- 4 min read
From the outside, you look confident.
You’re capable. Intelligent. Respected. You’ve earned your seat at the table — maybe several times over.
And yet…Inside, there’s a quiet unease you can’t quite shake.
You replay conversations after meetings.
You prepare obsessively before presentations.
You feel a pit in your stomach even when things are objectively going well.
You wonder, Why don’t I feel as confident as everyone thinks I am?
This is the confidence trap — and it shows up most clearly as imposter syndrome threatening your leadership. When confidence is built on achievement, it never lasts. You can hit the milestone, earn the title, or receive the praise — and still feel like it could all disappear at any moment.
Why Imposter Syndrome in Leadership Thrives on Achievement
High achievers are often taught that confidence comes after success.
After the promotion.
After the recognition.
After you prove yourself one more time.
And for a moment, it works.
You hit the milestone and feel a rush — relief, pride, validation.
See? I knew I could do it.
But then the next challenge appears.
A bigger role.
A higher-stakes room.
A new expectation.
And suddenly that confidence evaporates.
Imposter thoughts creep back in:
What if I can’t do this again?
What if they finally see I’m not as capable as they think?
This is the trap: when your confidence is tied to what you do, it will always feel fragile. Because achievements are temporary — and your nervous system knows it.
Why External Validation Never Creates Internal Safety
Titles, praise, and results are not bad things.
But they were never meant to be your foundation.
When confidence depends on external validation, your sense of worth becomes unstable. Your internal world rises and falls based on feedback, performance, and outcomes.
That’s why so many high-achieving women tell me:
“People think I’m confident, but inside I’m overthinking everything.”
“I’m more worried about what they think than my own sanity.”
“When something goes wrong, I immediately feel like I am the failure.”
This isn’t a confidence flaw.
It’s an identity issue.
You’ve learned to equate being valuable with performing well.
So even when you succeed, your system stays on edge — waiting for the next moment you might fall short.
The Real Reason Imposter Syndrome Sticks Around
Here’s the truth most leadership advice misses:
You don’t overcome imposter syndrome by collecting more proof of your competence.
You overcome it by untangling your identity from your output.
Real confidence isn’t loud.
It isn’t performative.
And it doesn’t come from racking up wins.
It comes from knowing — on a deep, embodied level — that you can fail without being a failure.
That you are allowed to be human, visible, imperfect… and still worthy of respect.
When confidence is rooted in identity rather than achievement:
You stop rehearsing every sentence before you speak.
You recover faster when things don’t go perfectly.
You care more about what you think than what others think.
You feel at home in your brilliance instead of trying to prove it.
That’s not arrogance.
That’s grounded self-trust.
My Own Run-In With the Confidence Trap
There was a point in my own career when I looked incredibly successful on paper — and quietly felt like a fraud.
New rooms. Bigger expectations. Higher visibility.
I kept thinking, If I just prepare more… if I just do better… then I’ll finally feel confident.
But no matter how much I achieved, that sense of safety never came.
Because the issue wasn’t competence.
It was the voice inside that said I had to earn the right to trust myself.
Once I started working with my inner critic — not ignoring it, not overpowering it, but understanding it — everything shifted.
My confidence stopped being something I chased… and became something I stood on.
The Way Out of the Trap
If you resonate with this, here’s what I want you to know:
You’re not broken.
You’re not behind.
And you don’t need to become someone else to feel confident.
You’ve just outgrown the version of confidence that got you this far.
The next level isn’t about doing more.
It’s about unlearning the belief that your worth lives outside of you.
That’s the work I guide women through every day — helping them quiet the inner critic, reclaim their authority, and lead from calm, clarity, and deep self-trust.
Ready for the Shift?
If you’re starting to see how the confidence trap has been running the show, the Hyper-Achiever Mini Course is a powerful place to begin.
It’s a 5-day reset designed to help you loosen the grip of achievement-based confidence and start building something real, grounded, and sustainable.
And if you’re ready for deeper, customized work — the kind that dismantles imposter syndrome at the identity level — my 1:1 coaching helps leaders stop overthinking and start leading from presence.
You don’t need more proof.
You need permission to trust who you already are.
And that? Changes everything.
Comments